Pages

Thursday, November 5, 2015

Draft of Public Argument

Here is my first draft of my public argument! Please feel free to compare it to examples I have provided previous to this and make lots of comments. Clarity, sentence structure, presentation of images, etc. I also feel as though my conclusion is weak and was unsure how to tie in the elements I wanted to discuss without making the paper too long. Enjoy and let me know what you think!

Stockman, Daniel "Corgi Puppies 36" March 12, 2011
Attribution Share Alike

Access the draft right HERE and here is an article you can compare it to XXX

Considering Visual Elements

This post will help my consider the visual aspects on my project based on the bulleted questions in Writing Public Lives.

Stockman, Daniel. "Corgi Puppies 28" March 2nd, 2013
Attribution Share Alike



What color choice best fits the rhetorical tone?
-I would like say a simple color scheme would be most appropriate. In the magazine I am basing my my article off of (Smithsonian Mag), the basic colors are black and white. Titles are frequently in black and grey.

If my project has a background, what color is most appropriate or visually engaging?
-This alternates between black text on white background or white text on a black background. I'll likely stick with black on white, seeing as it is more traditional and professional. However, I am still considering the white on black, since it is frequently seen in their articles and it is an engaging color choice. Maybe I will do a little bit of both. 

If your project contains large blocks of text, could they be broken up more effectively using text boxes, lines, headings, or images?
-Large sections or chunks of text are found often. Different topics in each section tend to be broken up by lines or images. I'll replicate this in my own project for sure. 

Does the text of headings need to stand out?
-There's generally one major heading and that's it, but it is extremely large compared to the rest of the text. I will likely also just have the one major heading that stands out and the rest will simply be divided by lines or, like how the Smithsonian does, a row of asterisks. ***************

Do too many visual images make your text busy or disorganized?
-Absolutely. There should be about 4 images per online article (though they often have options to click on other images that are less prominently displayed). The actual magazine will tend to have more, likely an upwards on 10 or so images. However, the format for these different forms of publication are fairly different. I will need to determine the format I absolutely want, and then make sure the images aren't a major distraction from the text. 

Does the image inform or emphasize my argument?
-Yes. They should be a direct illustration of what I am discussing. 

Is the theme or association that the images produces relevant to the theme of my argument?
-Yes. Like I said up above, it should be a literal image of what I am discussing in the text. 

If the image is a graph or chart, does it clearly support a major point of my argument?
-Graphs are fairly unlikely to be used in my project. If I do end up using them it needs to be in an exact fashion so that they are directly related and support my argument.




Project 3 Outline

In this post, I will provide a detailed outline in preparation for this next project. Pages 415-421 of Writing Public Lives will guide my outline.

wplynn "Macintosh the Pembroke Welsh Corgi", November 5th, 2006
Attribution no derivs


It ended up being a bit lengthy, so I created a Google doc available HERE

Reflection:

 I read Evan's  post on visual elements. Like my genre, his requires little to no images, and if it does they need to be very persuasive and placed carefully. He wrote more about what his genre was setting out to accomplish than the specific visual elements of the paper, so it was interesting to learn more about what he was trying to accomplish. I also read Chelsea's visual elements post. Chelsea thought more in-depth about the color choices she could utilize to get the best effect from her paper, and her images are already pre-selected to make the best effect. She seems more organized in considering her draft which makes me think I need to work on mine more for sure.

Analyzing My Genre

In this blog post, I will provide 5 examples of my planned genre and then will answer the bulleted questions provided below. 

Screenshot of WPL 342
Hallye Becker, Screenshot from my Computer, November 5th 2015

Social Context
  • The genre is typically set in an actual  magazine, or posted through that magazine's website. All of my examples come from smithsonianmag.com specifically. 
  • The specific subject is of all my examples are varied, but all pertain to history, archaeology, or art. (Look at examples to see varied ranges of topics)
  • People in this genre are generally reporting on new information relating to their subject. They will present their topic usually fairly in-depth, but magazines have limitations on generally how long their articles are. Writers are usually given (xx) amount of pages or words as a requirement that they have to fill. For the Smithsonian, most of them are professional and well respected authors or journalists. 
  • This genre is used a source of worldly information for casual and professional readers alike. It informs subscribers to the magazine (aka those who tend to care about these sort of topics) and presents them with news that pertains to the educated world. This includes revelations in science, history, art, travel, and new innovations.  

Rhetorical Patterns
  • Most articles tend to stick to the "who, what, when, where, how" sort of questions. Typically, this content is mostly informational. There is little extraneous information, and opinion pieces for magazines such as the Smithsonian are fairly uncommon. Even when opinion pieces do exist, they're very level-headed and fair. 
  • It could be argued that all three appeals are used. They need to present information and develop an argument, which means they need to appear credible and professional, but also need to appeal to their audience and create an emotional connection. Sometimes a logical argument serves an piece of news better than an emotional one, and vice versa. By carefully balancing all three appeals, an article can have lasting power with a reader.
  • Most articles tend to open with a hook that simultaneously serves to introduce the topic at hand. For example, in Example 2, the article opens with the tale of an exposed CIA intelligence officer. This serves to introduce the article about spy betrayal, while also creating a hook to draw the reader in. The conclusion is not always a perfect wrap up of the information. While it does serve to really accentuate the argument provided, it can also be open-ended, as a lot of the information provided is still open-ended.
  • The sentences are usually of varied structure, as good writing is supposed to be. They are professional and have a smooth flow, as magazine articles need to be easily and highly readable. They usually are presenting information, so question marks and exclamation points are typically reserved for extreme emphasis and quotations. 
  • Magazine articles have a very wide range of word choice, depending on the magazine. For the more specific genre I have chosen, the word choice is formal because it has a more scientific/academic focus. 

Analyzing Patterns
  • The genre is fairly inclusive. Whoever can afford a subscription to the magazine or chooses to read the articles online are part of the genre. For the place I would be writing my article, the audience is typically well educated and well-off financially. They have an interest in the world around them on a scientific level and can filter down to a more specific part of their interests by article. 
  • The genre encourages interaction and education between the writers and readers. Writers present the information and ideas, and readers can choose how to react to them in any multitude of ways. Since there isn't a ton of persuasion in fact based articles, it's mostly just presenting facts the audience can choose to interpret. 
  • It can be assumed they have an academic or scientific set of interests, and value research and learning new things about the world. 
  • Facts, studies, research, and well documented information is likely considered to be the "most valuable" content. Overly opinionated or "tabloid" pieces will be considered less valuable.



*********

Example 1
Example 2
Example 3
Example 4
Example 5


Reflection

 I read Swati's genre post first. Swati chose a more science-based genre than I, and mine will likely read in a more academic manner. Mine is based off of a magazine article while the hers is more based off a science-article website. While our audiences and genres are different, we do have similar approaches though. We both will use logical appeals, and have an assumption that out audiences will have a pre-existing interest in the genre.
I also read Chloe's post. Chloe is using the New York Times as the reference for her genre, which is similar to me choosing the New York Times. Her genre is really similar to mine then, and we had similar approaches to considering our audience and how we're going to write the paper. I would say that her analysis needs a little more depth, but otherwise everything is well organized and matches up with my own sort of genre.

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

Considering Types

This blog post will look at the different types of argument would be the most effective or least effective for my argumentation project.

Found Animals Foundation, "Cat Argument 4" August 29th, 2011
Attribution Share Alike
I believe either the Position argument or the Causal argument would be the best fit for my paper. Position arguments look at specific policy or ideas in a policy debate. For my own topic, I could discuss future plans with Pompeii (for example, the plan to add a train station) and argue the pros and cons of this plan. I could compare it to other failed or successful ideas and create an argument about Pompeii's handling by using a specific new plan. The Casual argument is an introduction to the causes of a specific problem, and argues for potential solutions as well. This would probably be the strongest fit, as I want to argue that Italy has failed to protect Pompeii, and this would be one of my "direct causes" towards the issue.

Probably the one that would fit this project the worst would be the Refutation. A Refutation argument has the specific purpose of refuting the opposing arguments for your topic. Seeing as I've been struggling to find people who openly speak against conservation or Pompeii, this would be a difficult paper for me to write. I can give good reasons as to why I believe my topic is important, but with little evidence to refute, the paper will be weak and one-sided.

REFLECTION

I read Chloe's Rhetorical Action Plan and her Considering Types post. After I had read her post, I ended up going back and changing one of my possible genres for this controversy. Therefore my rhetorical action plan is likely slightly more different than my initial comment on her post, but we were in agreement for the Considering types post. We both thought the Position argument style would be beneficial for our respective controversies, though I could see us using it in slightly different formats.
I also read Alex's Rhetorical Action Plan and Considering Types. Alex's paper was more concise than my own, and managed to generally cover everything. He chose to consider a more visual option, like a TED talk, which I think would be really interesting to watch. For his types post, we also both picked the causal and position arguments. However, Alex chose different levels of appropriateness for each type of argument. His blog post definitely went more in depth than mine did, and I may want to look over each type of argument again.
The comment I received encouraged me using an article format over an academic style paper, and I probably agree that would be more interesting.

My Rhetorical Action Plan

This blog post will have a somewhat in-depth response to a list of ideas to help me build my paper more strongly. This includes looking at audience, genre, type of arguments made, etc.
P.S. Happy 50th post!

prettyinprint, "Party Animal" October 27th, 2008
Attribution no derivs 


This became a bit too lengthy for a blog post, so I created a Google doc which can be found HERE

Reflection:

Coggle of Analyzing my Purpose

This blog post will have a link to a mind map discussing the purpose of my public argument.

A Health Blog, "Exercise plays A Vital Role in Maintaining Brain Health", April 24th, 2014
Attribution Share-Alike


It can be found right HERE
 
Copyright 2012 Hallye Becker's Blog. Powered by Blogger
Blogger by Blogger Templates and Images by Wpthemescreator
Personal Blogger Templates